Monday, December 03, 2007

Gotta get yourself connected

The title is part of a song by Stereo MC's called "Connected". I'm so sorry to those who think being connected in church is the be-all and end-all of life, but I just have to quote the lyrics. Although they have nothing to do with church at all, they fit perfectly.

If you make sure you're connected
The writing's on the wall
But if your mind's neglected
Stumble you might fall
Stumble you might fall
Hear me out
Stumble you might fall
Won't someone try
Open up your eyes
You must be blind
If you can't see
The gaping hole
Called reality

OK, now that I've had my fun.... since it seems your comments are done, here are my observations of this little video.


First of all, can I let you know that I have absolutely nothing against this particular church, I don't know them, I don't know what they do, I have heard nothing about them except what is on this video. So please don't see this as a personal attack.

There were a few things that bothered me about this. Many of them stem from Jason Zahariades' article Detoxing From Church.

I know I've quoted some of this before, but it's important to this discussion.

In the Americanized church, the organization is designed to turn life and faith into a simple prepackaged consumer product. This is what John Drane calls the “McDonaldization of the Church.”

  • I need to worship. So I go to my local church, which, if it’s cutting-edge, has a worship pastor on staff that prepares an inspiring "worship experience" for me on a weekly basis. One local church I know advertises its worship services on its marquee, "We worship five times, three ways, one God." (Hello! Is it me or does that just sound wrong?)
  • I also need to fellowship with my fellow Christians. So I go to my local church to attend a programmed version of community that provides a surface-level contact with people around some form of activity at my convenience. If I need more fellowship, I go to a small group, usually focused on the dynamic personality of the small group leader or on the subject matter I feel I need to better my life. But again, this is at my convenience and fairly optional if my schedule becomes too demanding.
  • I need discipleship and Christian growth. So I go to my local church to attend Sunday services, Bible studies and small groups where someone opens the Bible and tells me what it says and how it should apply to my life. I also have the option of learning "practical" topics such as how to be a good spouse, parent, employee, leader, steward, etc.
  • I need to serve. So I go to my local church and participate in a program where I use my time and skills in a fairly convenient manner to help others. For the most part, it’s fairly safe. And if I'm a volunteer, my participation is completely based on my schedule.
  • I need to be engaged in mission. So I go to my local church to connect to their evangelistic ministry and their missions program. Every so often I might volunteer to hand out sodas or serve coffee in a convenient and semi-relational form of "reaching people" for Christ. I might also give money to local missionaries the church supports and maybe participate in a weekend mission trip.
  • I need a children's program to educate my kids. So I go to my local church to place my children in the care of Sunday school teachers and youth pastors who will provide the spiritual and moral foundation for their Christian growth via an age-relevant program.
  • I need purpose for my life. So I go to my local church, hoping to find a leader with a vision big enough to inspire me. Then I sacrifice my time, energy, and money to become involved in the leader’s vision so I can build something big for God with him. New programs. New buildings. New projects. New groups. New services. New converts. New church plants. New missions. More and more and more vision to give my life a reason to exist.
Now, a few things specifically jumped out at me from this video.

1. "'Cos God picked the best of the best."

That bothers me hugely. God doesn't pick the best of the best at all. He picks us, whether we are the best or the worst, and shows us grace. He doesn't try to make us the 'best of the best' either - he wants us only to show his nature while authentically being ourselves.

2. "And they help me to be a better person and they help me to rise up to the occasion."

This one is a little less direct. What is wrong with being a better person? Nothing at all. However, if we're relying solely on other church members to make us better people, that is not really the best place to be.

To quote Jason again, I also need to fellowship with my fellow Christians. So I go to my local church to attend a programmed version of community that provides a surface-level contact with people around some form of activity at my convenience. If I need more fellowship, I go to a small group, usually focused on the dynamic personality of the small group leader or on the subject matter I feel I need to better my life. But again, this is at my convenience and fairly optional if my schedule becomes too demanding.

3. The comments about hair and fashion are just a bit pointless. I'm not going to critique that because it is meant as a joke. I hope.

4. "We love our team because it's our FAMILY!"

This sounds so lovely on the surface, especially with the big smiles and the beautiful little girl. The problem I have with this is, the whole church, worldwide, is our family. It seems here that this goes back to Jason Zahariades article "I need to serve. So I go to my local church and participate in a program where I use my time and skills in a fairly convenient manner to help others. For the most part, it’s fairly safe."

When it becomes necessary to be "plugged in" to a specific group in church in order to have the feeling of family, it could easily be a sign of addiction to church. See the quote from Jason at number 2 for this one as well.

5. "Because they're committed Christians and they want to see this church grow and expand and go out into all the world."

This is where I have a major theological rift with the "come to us" seeker-sensitive mentality. Yes, it's a whole 'nother discussion and it doesn't do it justice to try to deal with it over a couple of lines, but a singular church growing and expanding just doesn't sit right with me. I believe church should be a place of maturing us to a level where we can leave. That should be the main objective, not putting up big signs and advertising and telling people to come see our latest gimmick. We have this famous singer coming, this famous speaker. These people will rip telephone books in half for Jesus. These ones will entertain you. Come, come, come. Jesus said to his disciples "Come to me - I will take your burdens, I will give you rest." But then he said "Go. Go into all the world." I think we as a western church are stuck in the "Come" mentality but very few actually do any "Going". But like I said, a few lines don't do that justice.

6. Finally the slogan "Get Yourself Connected". It implies that the only way to be "connected" in the church is to join a team. Join hospitality, join the visitors lounge, join the childrens programs, join the carpark attendants. Join, join, join. With all this joining, how is there room for one to be missional outside the church walls? By the time you factor in small groups, staff meetings, music practices, committee meetings, volunteer training, turning up early to set up services, staying late to pack up services, womens groups, mens groups, youth groups, childrens groups, young adults groups, young married groups - the whole thing is just one big bubble. Where does mission come in? How are we to go out into the world?

And most of all, what happens to those who don't "Get Connected"? What if they just don't fit in to a group? What if their outside-church-walls mission (God forbid!) comes first, and they don't have time to do both?

I have been there. That is when the idea of "family" disappears. Family should be unconditional. Family should rely on each other. Family should be there whether you join a small group or not. Getting connected doesn't need to be part of the equation, I know because I am there now. I am not in a single small group or department, other than that I help out with the kids once or twice a month because I have kids and take my fair share of the load. And yet, I am the most "connected" I have ever been. Why? I am with a bunch of Christ-followers who care nothing about the internal workings of church and making it stand out from the crowd with special programs and promotions. They care for each other, they show each other support, they listen no matter how stupid you sound, and they focus on getting each other to a place where they can realise their ministry - not inside the church but outside. Missionally. To the world, where Jesus sent us.

It's an amazing thing when you see that happen.

So there you are. Now I am steeling myself for the barrage of comments. *ducks*

12 comments:

Sarah said...

I think you summarized the inward-focus, consumer-based North American church pretty well. I think you hint at it, but don't come right out and say it directly, so I will:

The problem (from my perspective) is that Christianity in North America has become all about "my personal growth and development." (This is the commodity on offer at your local church). It's the logical conclusion to a seeker-sensitive gospel, but goes much deeper - it's part of the absorption of the world culture around us. The church isn't supposed to reflect the consumer culture of the world, but alas, it does.

This commodified Christianity has become a journey of self-actualization (majoring on the 'self' part) rather than an embracing of the cross and the gospel of the kingdom (which will cost you something - it's definitely not a desirable consumer product). It's really not all about me. It's not about my spiritual growth, it's not about my understanding of scripture, it's not about my service and volunteer work. It's just not about me and my needs as a faith-based consumer.

Bob said...

So now we know what is *wrong* with *them*. Are we implying that the converse of all these statements points to what is *right* about *us*?

Sarah said...

Hi, Bob. I can't speak for Heather's motivations - I'm sure she can answer that from her distinctly Australian perspective. But I am part of the North American church, so I see this as a personal problem as much as a corporate problem. This is my family (the "church" in general) we are talking about, so it is not meant in a critical spirit, but in a desire for us to do better! We have to talk about the negatives sometimes in family life if we are going to move beyond them. Love doesn't ignore sin and pretend everything's okay when it isn't okay.

These issues of consumerism and self-focus are ones that I am tackling in my personal life, as well as trying to call others to journey with me to come closer to Christ's image. Maybe not a popular message, but that's not my concern - being Christlike is my concern, not tickling ears... :)

If someone gets their identity in being part of a certain type of church (traditional or emergent), rather than getting their identity in Christ, then offense comes in, and it becomes about 'us' and 'them'. But our identity is in Christ, not in these other things - so we shouldn't feel threatened when a fellow brother or sister holds a different perspective and wants to challenge us to think in new ways. That is an act of love, not divisiveness. It only becomes divisive when our identity is tied to something it shouldn't be. We are all one in Christ, regardless of church affiliation, denomination, emergent or traditional...

Heather said...

Sarah, thank you for your comments. I agree completely. Consumer church is really such a poor substitute to true community, and it's so difficult to see when you're the consumer. I don't think it is just the North American church though. Hillsong is from Australia, remember. We manage to do consumer church as well as the next country. I think most developed countries manage it pretty well, really.

Bob, I'm not implying anything about "us". Nor am I decrying "them". I am highlighting the insidious way that church becomes a commodity in our society. Yes, it bothers me. Yes, I try my best not to treat church or God as a consumer product now that I have recognised it. I'm certainly not attacking the people who are consumers. Honestly, they just don't see it that way. They really think that is the only way to "do church", and as that goes, the best way to do church. I simply try to highlight what I see so that perhaps others might see it from my perspective too, and rethink their standpoint. I wish somebody had told me at the time I was being a church consumer. It not so much "us" and "them" as "Hey, guys, look over here and see what I found!" I'm not expecting everybody to agree with me. That's fine, everybody makes their own decisions. I'm not doing the "I'm right, you're wrong" thing, I'm doing the "I noticed this, what do you think?" thing.

Keith said...

I'm not sure I even have a right to come here and post about this, since I don't even believe in God. *ducks*

But, Heather, from my generally agnostic point of view, your comments make perfect sense to me; in fact, these last few years living in Georgia, USA, have probably contributed to alienating me to the concept of a God simply because of the way churches seem to operate around here, and because of the way church-goers seem to switch from one place to another as if to see which suits them best. (I know this happens because I've seen it.) How fickle people are!

Ministers, priests, pastors and the like seem to treat the whole thing like a business -- well, perhaps it is in the sense that money is needed to run each church -- or worse, a sort of "my way is best so join my club" game. But something has to be wrong when there's a church on every street corner. On one road heading into Chattanooga there's a 100 yard stretch with five churches -- probably different denominations, but even so, to the agnostic like me it just seems ridiculous somehow. A hundred years ago you'd probably find one central church for each town, which to me makes far more sense.

It's all been shoved in my face a little since I moved here from England. Georgia is a genuine bible-belt region, and I find it amazing that the local people can "praise the Lord" and be so self-righteous considering the history of slavery and ongoing racism in the south, and sadly there are still fairly obvious traces of that racism left even today. I hate to say it, but I got annoyed with my mother-in-law recently because she was watching TV and she shook her head and asked, "Why on earth did that beautiful white girl marry that ugly black man?" (She was actually talking about Seal, the singer/songwriter, on the Oprah show.) I asked her why she thought that was wrong, and she said, "Wel, it's not that I think blacks are beneath us, but, well, I guess I was brought up to believe that blacks and whites shouldn't mix." This is a God-fearing, church-loving, and genuinely lovely woman who has some very backward (and in my opinion utterly ignorant) views about some of her fellow humans. Don't even get her started -- or anyone else around here -- on the subject of gay rights!

And then the same people try to convince me to bring my family to church to learn some "good Christian values." That makes me mad.

To me, it seems that the majority of religious people around here believe what they want to believe and reject what doesn't sit comfortably with their delicate sensibilities. Where's the sense in that? What's the point of it all? I just don't get it.

Sorry, just my two cents worth. :-)

Heather said...

Hi, Keith! It's great to see you in this forum! You are very welcome to comment here on any topic at any time. Please don't feel like you shouldn't because your beliefs differ from mine, although after reading your comment I don't think they do quite as much as you think!

It is actually more interesting hearing from you, and others who are viewing the church from the outside rather than the inside. It provides us with a different perspective, and God knows we all need that sometimes!

Thank you so much for sharing your observations. You're right. It doesn't make sense. It all seems upside down somehow. Here's hoping a little more dialogue between the churched and the unchurched can improve the perspective on both sides.

s g said...

Are you sure the video is even talking about a church? It could be an ad for a gym! I agree with each of your points though I'm still trying to wade through the "detoxing" link you provided.

Looking forward to exploring your site...

Nate said...

Crap I thought I made up that slogan for consumerized church at my post here. Well I totally agree.

Keith, I am in Buford Georgia and I understand perfectly your staements. That is one of the reasons that I don't take church seriously here. People have all been brought up in the church and mouth the platitudes that are in church vogue at the moment. Then go and cheat on their wife the next and don't see anything wrong with that. Because going to church isn't about being spiritual here, it is just something you do socially.

Then I get KKK on the word verification. Keith was just talking about racism. Too weird.

Heather said...

Nate, I wouldn't stress.

If it's true that great minds think alike, you thinking like Jason Zahariades and John Drane is pretty great!

bob said...

Sarah and Heather,

Sorry for the delay in responding. I understand what you're saying; I'm living what you're saying; I agree with what you're saying.

The thing is, I've gotten past the criticizing stage (the Deconstructed Christian) and am finding the "moving forward" stage is next to impossible 'cause no one is doing it (yet?).

I guess my point is, when does Deconstruction transition to Reconstruction?

Heather said...

Hi again, Bob.

It seems the reconstruction and the deconstruction go together. As things are deconstructed, new things form in that place.

I think you'll find that I don't spend this entire blog moaning about the evils of organised church. For example, out of eight posts in November, one was about how we hear from God, one was about what Jesus would say to me, and one was about the Kingdom of God. All of those had to do with reconstruction. In the same period I had one (slight) rant about misrepresenting God - not counting a couple of Asbo Jesus cartoons that I posted just because they were hilarious.

I don't really think it's so much a transition from deconstruction to reconstruction for me, as a gradual process that incorporates both. I don't know when I'll be done deconstructing. Possibly never. Because this blog is about what I'm thinking and feeling at any one time, it will likely always be a bit of both.

Yes, I can be critical at times, but I'm just as critical of myself as anybody else - probably more so. For me it's a healthy part of my journey, and it's part of how I learn and grow. I don't see it as a bad thing or something that is holding me back from moving forward.

I guess it's just a matter of perspective!

God go with you as you find your way along your path.

Nate said...

Hey Bob,
I can't jump to your site, so I will leave you a message here. There is a great book about what to do next. Called So You Don't Want To Go To Church Anymore it if downloadable for free, or it is about $10 US through Amazon. Check it out. Contact me with any questions you would like. It is easier to contact me through the blog as I do not check email every day.